SIGforum.com    Main Page  Hop To Forum Categories  The Lair    Dune
Page 1 ... 13 14 15 16
Go
New
Find
Notify
Tools
Reply
  
Dune Login/Join 
I swear I had
something for this
posted Hide Post
Fuck this shit. I'm out...

 
Posts: 5515 | Location: Kansas City, MO | Registered: May 28, 2004Reply With QuoteReport This Post
Member
Picture of konata88
posted Hide Post
I still haven't read the book yet but I take this to mean that the 3rd installment doesn't follow the book - that it's more true to zendaya (?; I still don't know who she is; I've been meaning to look up why she seems popular but haven't had sufficient interest to do so) than to the original story.

Or perhaps #3 doesn't generally follow the book at all?




"Wrong does not cease to be wrong because the majority share in it." L.Tolstoy
"A government is just a body of people, usually, notably, ungoverned." Shepherd Book
 
Posts: 15263 | Location: In the gilded cage | Registered: December 09, 2007Reply With QuoteReport This Post
I swear I had
something for this
posted Hide Post
The changes they did to Chani in Part 1 and Part 2 weren't horrible, but lack a good reason to do it in the movies. There is no possible way in Dune Messiah that Chani would fall in with the antagonists other than casting a self absorbed, self righteous SoCal girl so Zendaya Coleman could play her from experience.

I'm also going to call it now that they're going to use the line from Paul in Part 2 about how Chani "will come around in the end" to redeem the the Zendaya twat who's more ghola than Duncan Idaho to absolve her of her actions.

This message has been edited. Last edited by: DanH,
 
Posts: 5515 | Location: Kansas City, MO | Registered: May 28, 2004Reply With QuoteReport This Post
Member
Picture of konata88
posted Hide Post
I don't know the storyline so don't know what to expect but I thought that the fremen (including chani?) were good guys and that that Paul starts as a good guy but #2 suggested he becomes a bad guy? Again, not sure and planning to read the book soon ahead of #3 release.

The antagonists are the emperor and the ??? (I forgot who the bad guys were called in #1/2). So the preview suggests that Chani sides w/ the emperor / ??? ? I didn't really understand the preview. I couldn't even recognize Paul.

I don't get the Chani character role other than perhaps love interest / support for Paul. She doesn't seem like a leader, doesn't seem particularly competent or capable of anything special, doesn't seem to matter much. Perhaps she's more relevant in the book.

I just finished the McDevitt books and the Old Testament. Maybe I'll start Dune as I start the New Testament.




"Wrong does not cease to be wrong because the majority share in it." L.Tolstoy
"A government is just a body of people, usually, notably, ungoverned." Shepherd Book
 
Posts: 15263 | Location: In the gilded cage | Registered: December 09, 2007Reply With QuoteReport This Post
Member
posted Hide Post
I never read Dune Messiah, so I don’t have any expectations with regard to whether it follows the book or not. I just hope it’s a good movie and holds my interest.
 
Posts: 4048 | Location: South FL | Registered: February 09, 2007Reply With QuoteReport This Post
The Quiet Man
posted Hide Post
There are no real good guys in Dune. The Fremen are better than the Harkonens, but they are still a pretty savage group of extremists. The Atredis start out as probably the closest thing to good guys, but once they move to Arrakis and things play out as they do, Paul finds himself having to do some pretty shady things first to stay alive and then to steer humanity away from either stagnation or destruction. The scope of just how horrible some of these things are sets the stage for the 3rd and later books in the series.

God Emperor of Dune is where things get weird. At his worst Paul was a saint compared to what Leto II does in the name of putting humanity in the Golden Path.

I love the first book. I enjoyed the recent movies other than the absolute butchering of Chami as a character. I’ve got no interest in seeing Part 3.
 
Posts: 2806 | Registered: November 13, 2003Reply With QuoteReport This Post
The Joy Maker
Picture of airsoft guy
posted Hide Post
In the Dune universe there's bad guys, and then not as bad guys. If you're lucky you're born on a planet like Caladan with the Atreides in power. For the most part you'd probably have a fairly comfortable life, maybe you're a fisherman, maybe you farm, maybe you're a laborer. You're born, you live, you have some kids, there's good times and bad, and eventually you die in your bed. Nice. It's still a feudal system though, and the Duke can rule his fiefs any way he sees fit, so long as the Emperor gets his cut.

Or maybe you're born on Geidi Prime with the Harkonnens, and you work in a toxic pit that will kill you before you're 40, being choked out by bleeding tumors. Or maybe you're raped by the Baron before he murders you at 15. The "good" ending is probably in the gladiator ring, being stabbed by another slave. Oh yeah, they have slaves too. At least they'll keep you fed, probably. Nobody likes a fight that's over too soon.

There's a thousand other Houses, major and minor, they all run pretty much between the Atreides and the Harkonnen in terms of "good guy/bad guy".

Lets not even get into the Bene Tleilax and their breeding tanks, just hey, you notice you never see one of their women?



quote:
Originally posted by Will938:
If you don't become a screen writer for comedy movies, then you're an asshole.
 
Posts: 17355 | Location: Washington State | Registered: April 04, 2003Reply With QuoteReport This Post
Casuistic Thinker and Daoist
Picture of 9mmepiphany
posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by konata88:
I don't know the storyline so don't know what to expect but I thought that the fremen (including chani?) were good guys and that that Paul starts as a good guy but #2 suggested he becomes a bad guy? Again, not sure and planning to read the book soon ahead of #3 release.

Reading the books is a good idea...I read them back when I was in college and re-reading them before the current films does put a different spin on it.

Paul doesn't become the "bad guy", he just isn't brave enough to follow through with The Golden Path and defers it to his son

quote:
I don't get the Chani character role other than perhaps love interest / support for Paul. She doesn't seem like a leader, doesn't seem particularly competent or capable of anything special, doesn't seem to matter much. Perhaps she's more relevant in the book.

She plays a much more important role in the movies than in the books.

In the book, she was the love interest, but also critical to Paul's transformation.

In the movies, she serves as a reminder of Herbert's intent...from the original book, that lead him to write the second to correct folks mis-understanding the first




No, Daoism isn't a religion



 
Posts: 14553 | Location: northern california | Registered: February 07, 2003Reply With QuoteReport This Post
Don't Panic
Picture of joel9507
posted Hide Post
IMO the books jumped galaxies of sharks between books 2 and 3, so it is not - again IMO - necessarily a bad thing the movies and the books diverge.

If as the trailer says the third movie is to be the final one, that divergence would have to be the case anyway.

So I'm looking forward to catching the third movie when it comes out.
 
Posts: 15834 | Location: North Carolina | Registered: October 15, 2007Reply With QuoteReport This Post
Member
Picture of konata88
posted Hide Post
I didn't know before but it seems like I need to read Dune (movies #1, 2) as well as Dune Messiah (movie #3) ahead of its release.

I've started Dune.... Chapter 1 was good and sounded familiar. Chapter 2 not so much. Onward ho....




"Wrong does not cease to be wrong because the majority share in it." L.Tolstoy
"A government is just a body of people, usually, notably, ungoverned." Shepherd Book
 
Posts: 15263 | Location: In the gilded cage | Registered: December 09, 2007Reply With QuoteReport This Post
I swear I had
something for this
posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by joel9507:
IMO the books jumped galaxies of sharks between books 2 and 3, so it is not - again IMO - necessarily a bad thing the movies and the books diverge.


What was wrong with Children of Dune? I thought it was the best book outside of the first and a great stop for the series like Sci-Fi Channel did on their miniseries. Or are you thinking of God Emperor of Dune, and if so, I agree 100%. If you thought you hated "The Message" for the Modern Audience, imagine a gigantic worm/human preaching at you for almost 500 pages.

quote:
I don't know the storyline so don't know what to expect but I thought that the fremen (including chani?) were good guys and that that Paul starts as a good guy but #2 suggested he becomes a bad guy? Again, not sure and planning to read the book soon ahead of #3 release.


I get the feeling they may circle back to this towards the end, but once Paul became the Kwisatz Haderach (Shortening of the Way in Hebrew), he became trapped by prophecy. You could borrow the example of Doctor Strange in Avengers: Infinity War that he knows every permutation, but there is only one path (The Golden Path) that will keep humanity from stagnating into extinction. Except the "best ending" is horrific and will cause a lot of suffering for a lot of people including Paul and everyone he is close to. If he doesn't follow this path, it's much worse for all of humanity, and I'm predicting the self-righteous and self-absorbed Chani will figure this out at the end and Paul will forgive her because he already knew it was going to happen. "She'll come around in the end..."
 
Posts: 5515 | Location: Kansas City, MO | Registered: May 28, 2004Reply With QuoteReport This Post
Don't Panic
Picture of joel9507
posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by DanH:
quote:
Originally posted by joel9507:
IMO the books jumped galaxies of sharks between books 2 and 3, so it is not - again IMO - necessarily a bad thing the movies and the books diverge.


What was wrong with Children of Dune? I thought it was the best book outside of the first and a great stop for the series like Sci-Fi Channel did on their miniseries. Or are you thinking of God Emperor of Dune, and if so, I agree 100%.

You're right, I got the numbers wrong. The shark-jumping (again IMO) was between 3 and 4.
 
Posts: 15834 | Location: North Carolina | Registered: October 15, 2007Reply With QuoteReport This Post
I swear I had
something for this
posted Hide Post
For those interested I found the SciFi Channel miniseries Frank Herbert's Dune and Frank Herbert's Children Of Dune free on YouTube with time codes and subtitles for those interested. These are the best and truest adaptations of the first 3 Dune novels made to date and deserve to be seen.



 
Posts: 5515 | Location: Kansas City, MO | Registered: May 28, 2004Reply With QuoteReport This Post
Member
Picture of konata88
posted Hide Post
I don't remember sex scenes in the book or current movies....

I just skimmed through the first video - perhaps it's truest to the books but the acting and the sets are a little dated / stiff. I think I like Chani in the miniseries over the movies though.

I'm still reading the book - I'm at the point where Paul has been invited into the seitch, so perhaps the beginning of movie #2. I need to finish the book and also Messiah before #3 is available on streaming (and/or UHD Blu-ray).

I better understand the comments about book Chani and movie Chani.




"Wrong does not cease to be wrong because the majority share in it." L.Tolstoy
"A government is just a body of people, usually, notably, ungoverned." Shepherd Book
 
Posts: 15263 | Location: In the gilded cage | Registered: December 09, 2007Reply With QuoteReport This Post
Casuistic Thinker and Daoist
Picture of 9mmepiphany
posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by konata88:
I better understand the comments about book Chani and movie Chani.

Denis has said that his use of Chani is purposely completely different than how she is portrayed in the books.

Herbert wrote the second book to correct how the first book was perceived. Denis uses Chani in the same way; to warn of the danger of believing in the (white) savior...trading one overlord for another




No, Daoism isn't a religion



 
Posts: 14553 | Location: northern california | Registered: February 07, 2003Reply With QuoteReport This Post
Charmingly unsophisticated
Picture of AllenInAR
posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by konata88:

I just skimmed through the first video - perhaps it's truest to the books but the acting and the sets are a little dated / stiff. I think I like Chani in the miniseries over the movies though.



If memory serves, it was shot in Czechoslovakia (Prague?) so that may explain the sets. I remember thinking some of the scenes looked like a theater play with a painted backdrop.

Great series though. Seeing Saskia Reeves in "Slow Horses" is a bit of a shock after watching it however.


_______________________________

The artist formerly known as AllenInWV
 
Posts: 16548 | Location: Harrison, AR | Registered: February 05, 2004Reply With QuoteReport This Post
I swear I had
something for this
posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by 9mmepiphany:
Denis has said that his use of Chani is purposely completely different than how she is portrayed in the books.

Herbert wrote the second book to correct how the first book was perceived. Denis uses Chani in the same way; to warn of the danger of believing in the (white) savior...trading one overlord for another


And it's terrible. Herbert also did a far better job introducing that theme than Villeneuve has over two movies and $300ish million. On the other hand, Herbert was also too stupid to reconcile that a hero can also be a tragic figure, and Paul never asked for what happened to him at all.

quote:
If memory serves, it was shot in Czechoslovakia (Prague?) so that may explain the sets. I remember thinking some of the scenes looked like a theater play with a painted backdrop.


The funny story behind that is the production hired Vittorio Storaro, one of the greatest Cinematographers in Movie history (Apocalypse Now, Reds, and The Last Emperor for some Oscar winning examples), to light the movie. Writer/Director John Harrison wanted to use blue screen set extensions for the desert shots, but Storaro convinced him that he could make a translight backdrop (giant painting/picture that can react to on set lighting) work better. Not only did they go with his idea and not have it work very well, the sand they ordered to match the sand in the translight were two different colors. As is the case in low budget movie production, all of this was discovered way to late to do anything about and they couldn't shoot around it because it ate so much of the budget.

Obviously, they did not make that same mistake in Children of Dune where they also got a much better VFX studio for that production.
 
Posts: 5515 | Location: Kansas City, MO | Registered: May 28, 2004Reply With QuoteReport This Post
  Powered by Social Strata Page 1 ... 13 14 15 16 
 

SIGforum.com    Main Page  Hop To Forum Categories  The Lair    Dune

© SIGforum 2026