quote:

Originally posted by iron chef:
I realize it must be hard for many of you to believe, but the Trojan War took place some time between 1200-1300BC, and the average Greek soldier resembled Elliot Page's build a lot more than the Spartans depicted in 300.

If so, than the rest of the cast should be equal in stature, instead Page is the glaring outlier. The average Bronze Age male was around 5'5'- 5'8', Page sits well below that average. Stature wise, regardless of being a farmer, craftsman, merchant, sailor, etc...you worked with your hands/arms all the time, muscle definition was much more common than today. Page not only lacks height but any muscle definition whatsoever.
I believe Page's role is as a pathetic character, similar to Ephialtes of Trachis who betrayed the Spartans at Thermopylae, who in the course of the retelling has been portrayed as a physically & mentally wretched individual; the most extreme was being a monstrous hunchback in the Frank Miller 300 book/movie.

quote:

Let me explain in a way an 8 y/o would be able to understand.

Murphy was 112 lbs when he enlisted. WWII was 80+ years ago. People on average were significantly smaller then. The Trojan War was 3,200+ years ago. People were substantially smaller than. It's not a stretch for someone 5'1", 106 lbs to play a Greek solder from that era.

Ok, let me explain this in a way that a 3-5 year old could understand:
Daddy is a Man, which is XY genes.
Mommy is a Female with is XX genes. Mommy can have a baby which Daddy can't, but Daddy gets to help in the process.
See, I can be condescending too.

Now you have been comparing a LA coffee house flop female who is surgically/chemically cosplaying as a male with an actual male who grew up in hard scrabble Texas during the Depression and became a War Hero. See the difference (again, I am being a condescending prick ).

So, Page is historically accurate in height and potential size to a Greek Warrior at that time, except she is an actual biological female (pesky DNA versus feeling like a man). Great, Nolan is going for historically accurate.....but he isn't by the casting (blacks but no Greeks), armor, weapons, ships, etc. Oh, and a trans "Man" as a Greek Warrior (but think of all the memes!), but damn if that didn't check a Blackrock DEI box. The cast is straight out an LA hipster coffee house and bar.

They took one of the foundational pieces of Western Literature and made it a DEI caricature.

Next up, the Chinese classic "Journey To The West" but casted with Hispanic and Black transgenders as the Monkey King and company to update it for modern audiences. In fact, make it a Rap song musical! Crap, I may have just given Hollywerid an "idea".

It is utterly ridiculous, crazy to even discuss height, weight, build, stature, etc, when it is all perfectly moot. Why? Because of the elephant in the room- Ellen Page is a woman, a mentally ill woman pretending to be a man. Who had a deranged doctor cut off her tits in a useless crazy attempt to resemble a man. And some idiot cast her to play a male Greek warrior in a big budget period piece, with the same idiot casting a black African American woman to play the daughter of a Greek God, the most beautiful woman in Greek mythology, in a period piece.

This is wretched Hollywood D.E.I. virtue signaling bullshit, this film has sunk pathetically low as Disney ever did.

quote:

Originally posted by downeastnc1:
I can't possibly understand how there is any debate about whether to watch this or not.

Same with me.

Nolan has used Page before. The Page was in Inception. Nolan often uses the same collaborators.

https://www.imdb.com/list/ls025424824/

So it’s not the first film for him using the Page. None of us agree with these controversial casting decisions. All I’ve stated is the Academy changed their rules, and Hollyweird followed suit for funding. Then you have to accept the fact that business has pivoted to Gen Z. They aren’t chasing the boomer generation, Gen X, or even Millennials anymore. They are chasing that Gen Z $. And this generation is all about inclusion, and diversity. They have been brainwashed on it since birth. Why do you think Zendaya was cast? She is in the biggest 3 films of this year. The latest Spidey-boy film with her man. Nolan’s film. And Dune 2 later this year. Why? Gen Z worships her. Probably why Nolan jammed her into this. I don’t think she is a bad actress but she is no Streep either so it’s tired.

I highly doubt these controversial casting decisions will even have much screen time honestly. To me seems like a checkbox that needed to be checked for funding, to get nominated, or both. And to appease that previously mentioned generation. Damn shame but doesn’t mean the film will suck. I think Nolan used this bs to his advantage. Wish it wasn’t so but this is the world today. It’s a fictional story and I’ll watch it at the end of the year.

quote:

Originally posted by iron chef:
There are six people on that stage, and only the guy to Page's right could be argued to pass more convincingly as Greek soldier.

I realize it must be hard for many of you to believe, but the Trojan War took place some time between 1200-1300BC, and the average Greek soldier resembled Elliot Page's build a lot more than the Spartans depicted in 300.

quote:

Ok, comparing a 5 foot nothing biological female who is only known for surgical/chemical cosplaying as a man with an actual man who is also a war hero....yeah that is something I never thought to see.

Let me explain in a way an 8 y/o would be able to understand.

Murphy was 112 lbs when he enlisted. WWII was 80+ years ago. People on average were significantly smaller then. The Trojan War was 3,200+ years ago. People were substantially smaller than. It's not a stretch for someone 5'1", 106 lbs to play a Greek solder from that era.

By that logic, the average hoplite would be the size of Jerry the mouse.