Last month, I picked up a like new HD P4.5 for a great deal. These are pistols I didn't think I'd like when I first heard of them, but now, being the owner of two, my thoughts have clearly changed.
The HD series is similar to Staccato 2011's, but uses Glock magazines and a Series 80 FPS design. While I'm not a fan of firing pin safeties on 1911's and 1911-like pistols, the HD triggers are the nicest Series 80 triggers I've ever felt. Overall quality is very high, in typical Staccato fashion. I also find the grip textering the best that Staccato offers.
The HD ergonomics are better for me than are Staccato's 2011 models and the guns point extremely well. I'm not an optics guy, but find the small rear sight immediately lines up when I raise the pistol. I find these handguns to be excellent shooters, optics or not.
Another fan of the 4.5. I absolutely love shooting that gun it is so smooth. If it were not for the fact I already have a 2024 C Staccato I would probably get the 3.6. I like the idea of the CX but it is so expensive.
________________________ "Don't mistake activity for achievement." John Wooden, "Wooden on Leadership"
Posts: 1426 | Location: Gilbert, AZ | Registered: November 08, 2000
I couldn't get used to the forward rear sight. I ended up buying a Dawson plate for my C3.6 that moved the rear sight to the rear. And it was a PITA to knock that rear sight pin out. lol
A great idea, cheap common magazines in an entirely different gun. You can get 2011 mutants to take Glock, Sig, and CZ magazines. Along with original STI types, why would anybody bring out a proprietary magazine?
Posts: 3494 | Location: Florence, Alabama, USA | Registered: July 05, 2001
I have a '24C as well full grip and it's an amazing shooter for sure but the lust for the C4X is strong.
Debated the 3.6 but after handling one and comparing I'd grab a P4 before I ever grabbed a 3.6.
quote:
Originally posted by SigLaw: Another fan of the 4.5. I absolutely love shooting that gun it is so smooth. If it were not for the fact I already have a 2024 C Staccato I would probably get the 3.6. I like the idea of the CX but it is so expensive.
Posts: 779 | Location: H6 | Registered: December 07, 2008
Originally posted by Jim Watson: Along with original STI types, why would anybody bring out a proprietary magazine?
In Bul Armory's case, they're better in every way than the STI 2011 style magazine, holds more rounds, and MecGar's are less expensive than even the Checkmate mags. I can drop one of those mags and not have rounds shoot out the top of the magazine, but to be fair I've not been able to test the new MecGar 2011 magazines if they're the same or not.
As for the HD line, they're priced higher than they should be for the performance you get, and I hate the new "trim lines" bullshit that Staccato has gone to. There is 0% reason why you should only get 2 or 3 magazines when you can buy additional mags for $20 a pop when you're spending $2.5-3K a gun, and it should come with one FREE spacer plate for the RMR or a coupon like Walther puts in their PDPs to get a free spacer of your choice mailed to you after you buy the gun.
Staccato has gotten too cocky in recent years, but at least if I did buy one that had hot spots near the safeties that still get complaints, Staccato will given me a priority shipping label to get it fixed ASAP.
Posts: 5370 | Location: Kansas City, MO | Registered: May 28, 2004
Between my various 2011 mag guns, I found MecGar mags to work best. Never had an issue. I have issues with my Checkmate UHC (19rd flush fit) and 20rd mags. Doesn't matter the gun. It's the mags.
I'd really like to get some time on the P4.5. I have no real need for it and feel like I would prefer a 5" or longer slide so I haven't really acted on it.
Posts: 5490 | Location: Iowa | Registered: February 24, 2011
I've heard from those who have shot the P4.5HD that it shoots like a longer gun, so it's probably the closest we will get to a 5" HD. I'm also wondering if it could be used as a standoff device so if the gun is against someone it won't bump the slide out of battery.
Posts: 5370 | Location: Kansas City, MO | Registered: May 28, 2004
Originally posted by DanH: I've heard from those who have shot the P4.5HD that it shoots like a longer gun, so it's probably the closest we will get to a 5" HD. I'm also wondering if it could be used as a standoff device so if the gun is against someone it won't bump the slide out of battery.
Nope. It's still attached directly to the barrel and will push the gun out of battery.
Posts: 5490 | Location: Iowa | Registered: February 24, 2011
Originally posted by DaBigBR: I'd really like to get some time on the P4.5. I have no real need for it and feel like I would prefer a 5" or longer slide so I haven't really acted on it.
Are you shooting a 5 inch of some sort in LO?
________________ People hate you. Train like it.
Posts: 38535 | Location: Logical | Registered: September 12, 2004
