The Hornady A-MAX bullet has reportedly been discontinued and evidently replaced by the ELD line that features bullets with plastic tips that are heat resistant and whose ballistic coefficients don’t change in flight due to melting.
I couldn’t find a statement by Hornady that A-MAX bullets shouldn’t be used for hunting; on the contrary there are many Internet reports of their use. The link below is not for the squeamish (i.e., NSFW—?) but shows some examples. That article does point out, though, that A-MAX bullets are somewhat frangible and that indicates to me that they and anything of similar construction should be limited to smaller species of “large” game and shots should be limited to those that would not require deep penetration to reach the animal’s vitals. And unsurprisingly, the heavier versions of the A-MAX line usually penetrated deeper.
https://www.ballisticstudies.c...-+Hornady+A-Max.html Of some possible significance is that A-MAX and now ELD Match bullets are used in Hornady’s Tactical Application Police (TAP) line of cartridges. In my experience cartridges in the TAP line are virtually as precise as Hornady’s Match lineup. Two A-MAX bullets, 155 and 168 grain, were used in the 308 Winchester chambering, and during the one gelatin test I observed some years ago the 155 grain A-MAX bullet penetrated less than the 168. At least one prominent law enforcement sniping authority strongly endorsed the 155 gn. TAP load, and it was what I specified for my agency’s SWAT snipers. Human beings are of course considered to be “thin skinned” and a bullet that penetrates less can be important for LE applications. At one time Hornady even offered a 110 grain TAP “Urban” load that featured what appears to be an A-MAX bullet and which was touted for its limited penetration. According to Hornady’s data, from an 18" barrel the 110 grain bullet penetrated less than 10 inches in ballistic test gelatin, the 155 gn. bullet 14", and the 168 gn. 17".
So, can the A-MAX and now the ELD-Match bullets be used for hunting? Obviously yes, but that doesn’t mean they’re ideal and that there are not better choices, especially for certain situations.
“Most men … can seldom accept the simplest and most obvious truth if it … would oblige them to admit the falsity of conclusions … which they have woven, thread by thread, into the fabrics of their lives.”
— Leo Tolstoy