Go | New | Find | Notify | Tools | Reply |
Member |
I carry Critical Duty, but after some extensive gel tests across different calibers and loads, I’ve come to the following conclusions/loads with the modern ammo we have today: In short-barreled 9mms, I use Federal 150gr HST. Low recoil and low muzzle flash. If that’s not available, I use std. pressure 147gr HST. In 4” or longer 9mms, I use Hornady Critical Duty 135gr +P, but, especially for longer barrels (Beretta 92, Browning Hi-Power, Glock 34, Walther Q5) I’m liking Lehigh Defense 90gr FTM +Ps. When I first started in LE, we had to carry a 4” 357 Mag. The issue ammo was Remington 125gr SJHP, but we could carry other ammo if we provided it for ourselves. I usually carried 145gr Silvertips (not a great choice, but it was the 80s, so not many options). In the early 90s they let us switch to semi-autos, provided they were in 10mm or 45. I was the only 10mm guy. --------- If you appreciate private ownership of firearms, please join the NRA, before it's too late. (Benefactor Member) | |||
|
Alienator |
IMHO, I would have both. I carry a P938 SAS in the summer and carry my P220 SAS in the winter. Carry what you are most comfortable and train with. I don't feel under equipped with either and carry Federal HST's in both. SIG556 Classic P220 Carry SAS Gen 2 SAO SP2022 9mm German Triple Serial P938 SAS P365 FDE Psalm 118:24 "This is the day which the Lord hath made; we will rejoice and be glad in it" | |||
|
Inject yourself! |
Bump. I stumbled on some standard pressure 147gr HST to try in the Shield and CZ P-01. I’m looking forward to testing. Do not send me to a heaven where there are no dogs. Step Up or Stand Aside: Support the Troops ! Expectations are premeditated disappointments. | |||
|
Member |
BUMPING this up. Like a lot of posts here there's lots of good info. | |||
|
Member |
Ummm... did anyone notice the 230 gr Ranger T that expanded to 1 inch and still penetrated 14 inches? Holy hell!!! ----------------------------------------- Roll Tide! Glock Certified Armorer NRA Certified Firearms Instructor | |||
|
Member |
Gun Sam Revolver aficianado has a lot of really good tests on youtube I will say that I have used the +p vesrions of 147 9mm and the 230 grain 45 to take whitetail deer. Both from 5" 1911s. Though the expansion difference was not enough to matter and neither deer died any faster or slower. Both were heart shot about 12 yards from the same blind and both expired within 35 yards. Neither bullet exited the off side but both broke a rib upon entry and got full exoansion, coming to rest in the hide on the offside. "Dyin ain't much of a livin...boy" | |||
|
Member |
Excellent write up, para. Completely agree with everything you said. | |||
|
Member |
Here is the often cited FBI report: http://gundata.org/images/fbi-handgun-ballistics.pdf He address diameter on page 10, and I am paraphrasing, since I can't seem to cut and paste his exact words: As to diameter, he says the larger diameter bullet will have an edge in wounding ... but that edge can not be quantified. | |||
|
Semper Fidelis Marines |
all im saying is that 115+115= 230 LOL I do know (personally) an officer that was involved in an OIS w/the hornady critical duty 135gr, he shot thru a car back windshield and struck the suspect in the forehead from a distance of about 8 yards, the round only dented, yes dented, the suspects forehead and did not penetrate, maybe a fluke maybe not. IDK but it (the round) had not garnered much respect from its users then(@ 5 years ago). big holes make big holes. FWIW I run a 40 cal glock with 180 gr Ranger Ts and my pers pref is the 357 sig when I can get it thanks, shawn Semper Fi, ---->>> EXCUSE TYPOS<<<--- | |||
|
The Ice Cream Man |
Purely the opinion of a middle-aged fat man: In which platform will your carry ammo and your practice ammo have the most similar recoil impulse and POI? If your practice volume is financially limited, which can you afford to shoot more? Is a SIRT trainer/other simulator available for the platform? Will you use/buy such a simulator? Which platform are you willing to be familiar with? EG, I usually carry/shoot a snubbie with wadcutters. The POA/POI line up very well, and I practice with the ammo I carry. My brother is one of those annoyingly gifted shooters, and carries a 7.5 on a ranch in S Texas, to make snap shots on pigs, when he can’t get to his AR 10 fast enough, as do the other folks on the ranch, but I think that’s a particular situation. In my father’s generation, men carried longer barreled SAA in 357, but also mostly rode. (Predated the era of the 4 wheeler.) | |||
|
"Member" |
Troy Fowler, a rather divisive / controversial character in the bow hunting world promotes the use of what he calls "A plan B arrow". Meaning anything works great if it hits them in the prefect spot, and/or the arrow head works exactly like it's supposed to. But this arrow system will work pretty good even when it doesn't. I think the .45 can be looked at today as a plan B arrow. | |||
|
Powered by Social Strata | Page 1 2 3 |
Please Wait. Your request is being processed... |