My votes were:

9mm SigPro 2009
.40 X5 L1
12ga Benelli

Polymer 9mm for carry, could also be used as a nightstand gun.

.40 X5 L1 for home duty, more likely for admiring its craftsmanship. and keeping something with sentimental value may make the move easier.

12ga Benelli for home defense

Two pistol calibers might help the current and future dry spells.

These are not listed as choices, but you have enough to trade/sell into them. I would think it's highly preferable that the two pistols are the same caliber. So if you were starting with a clean slate, I'd say Glock 19, Glock 43, and 16" AR in 5.56. Seems like that would cover 99.9% of all potential defensive situations with readily available ammo.

Of course this in no way answers the exact question you asked, so feel free to disregard completely.

quote:

Originally posted by Hildur:

For consideration purposes here's my inventory for carry ammo/accessories:

1,200+ .40 S&W Speer Gold Dots...

That would narrow it down a bit. I voted for the G23 Carry and X5 L1 for home defense.

Rifle choice would depend on ammo availability.