I'd have to think on that for a while. I can say for sure that it is not one of the plastic ones....

The classic P225. For me, the perfect Sig. I now have 3, including a 39 year old Suisse Montage model.

The P239 gen2 .40sw. In 2nd place, P239 gen2 SAS 9mm.

Maybe it's not a 'pistol' in the traditional sense but BAFTE deems it one and that's good 'nuff for me: MPX with brace. Crazy, silly smile fun. Had a session with a buddy's TA31 in place of my RMR...now I wanna ACOG. Yeah...it's THAT fun. Makes me WANT to blow serious money on it, just for the HELL of it.

As for a traditionalist format SIG pistol: I'm a goddamned Glock guy. I should prefer the 320 but it truly points poorly for me, worse than even the classic guns do. Nearly all of those so-called 'classic' SIGs kinda feel more or less the same, though I like them almost equally and well enough for what they are considering my striker sensibilities and preference. I used to think that the P228 was my favorite SIG, but now I like how X-Fives and pre-Legend P210s shoot. And I find that I prefer the pre-dash P229 over its folded slide predecessor, especially the mid-90s 40S&W that I own and now my CC TALO. And then there's my two P220 SSEs and my Mk25. And the SIGPro 2022. Then there's my P6 and P225. All great choices in my opinion. Me picking one above all the rest out of this bunch...I say it be impossible for me to do. It would be easier to weed out the losers, but that's something for another thread.

Swiss Sig P210. I’m old school.

SIG P226 Legion

.40 S&W

My favorite is my P6, closely followed by my 225A1.

OP, nice collection! And not a rail in the bunch

Oh, and 12131, that is just sick!! Well done Sir!!!!!

My P239 .40/.357/9mm

This message has been edited. Last edited by: Battlecloth,

I'm thoroughly convinced that Q either aspires to own 228 P228s, or already owns that many. Looking forward to the P228 pistol layout picture with all 228 P228s in it.

Here is my KG two-tone nickel P228. My first SIG (bought new) and my favorite SIG.

Honorable mention to my 9mm P226 Stainless Elite and .45ACP P220 Stainless Match Elite 5" which tie for 2nd place.

I'd have to say my it's my old sentimental favorite, a 1995 P229 DA/SA .40. It was my first Sig.

Utterly reliable and accurate over a 23 year span. Have about 47,000 rounds through it. Slide and frame rails look like they're nicely broken in now. I'll report back after the next 47,000 rounds.

Currently sports:

1) Sig bead blasted slide.

2) Heinie black/black sights.

3) GrayGuns P-SPIT trigger.

4) G10 checkered grips.

5) My own DA action work. Very smooth DA, very crisp SA.

No reflection on the rest of my Sigs, but rather the fact that this P229 is like a well broken in pair of boots.

MK25 for me.

P220st!

I like the SIG P229 Nitron with no-rail frame and legacy slide, 18 lb mainspring, SRT, and P-SAIT trigger.

225 without a doubt....Zebulon

quote:

Originally posted by Excam_Man:
Top: ?, 225, 226/DAO/DAK, 229, 220, 220C

...

That's a Mauser M2.

P226

P226

KA P228 with a Burke QRT trigger job.

AB triple serial numbered P229 in 40 cal. I carry it with a 357 Sig barrel now. Only modifications were night sites and a Grayguns recoil spring guide rod. Fantastic ultra-reliable shooter and very comforting to carry in this lovely state.