If a pullover is what you’re after, the 5.11 PT-R Catalyst might be worth a look.

I bought one this past spring to take on an overnight hunt. It’s lightweight, non-bulky, and reasonably warm (for calm 55-degree nights). It’s got the thumbhole sleeves, which I a) didn’t realize when I bought it and b) thought were a little weird when I noticed them and c) actually like of liked when being out one cooler-than-expected night.

Thanks smiling, cloister, and vthoky, those all look like good options. I have a Columbia lightweight zip fleece on order and I'll see how that is before buying a second one. I want two, one to leave in each vehicle.

If you're set on a sweater I would go with a nice merino wool blend, or cashmere if you want to spend a little more. So much more comfortable than cotton, imo.
A cardigan like this: https://bonobos.com/products/i...ue%20boucle%20cotton
or a simple crewneck pullover: https://bonobos.com/products/w...eater?color=bordeaux

Or might I suggest a shirt-jac like this:
SG_2300061811881_pla_aud-1231866930227la-2300061811881_163448662242_21255329218&segment=&gclsrc=aw.ds&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=21255329218&gbraid=0AAAAADv4bTbNT6BA_POSO6hrV2QxvArfx&gclid=CjwKCAjwxb7RBhA5EiwAQ-AAdDR9zbLUpfZ4FmaIceOD2JwHvUpGwpuRHiBpvcikZIxM8t0PHSrRAhoCddgQAvD_BwE" target="_blank">https://www.dickssportinggoods...PHSrRAhoCddgQAvD_BwE

Or a casual blazer like this (I have two of these, one in navy, one tan, and wear the heck out of them): https://bonobos.com/products/j...color=washed%20olive

quote:

Originally posted by YellowJacket:
If you're set on a sweater I would go with a nice merino wool blend, or cashmere if you want to spend a little more. So much more comfortable than cotton, imo.
A cardigan like this: https://bonobos.com/products/i...ue%20boucle%20cotton

Actually that cotton one might work well. I had something similar for years and it finally wore out. Thanks!