I have been carrying my P238 in a Super Fly for about 5 years now. Well it is time for a new holster and I wondered if you would stay with the Super Fly or go to a Sticky holster or maybe something else. I carry every day in shorts and pants with cargo pockets since it doesn't work well with jeans or regular shorts. Any help will be welcome.

Don't know if this will help much but I have acquired a number of holsters for my P238 over the years since buying the pistol in 2010. They serve different situations.

RKBA leather pocket holster
Remora "No Clip" IWB #2P-SS PlusMag holster
Remora OWB-2ART holster
Blackhawk 421433BN-R leather IWB clip
Remora pocket magazine pouch

The Remora IWB (great for beltless carry) and RKBA pocket holster have seen the most use. The Remora OWB is one I frankly dislike as it is "fiddly" to adjust on a belt so it has been rarely used and classed as a regretful acquisition. The Blackhawk is the newest having been bought only a couple months ago and has been worn both inside my pants as well as between belt and pants which has become my preference with this holster.

The Remora OWB holster is shown with the velcro flap pulled back and the magazines in the pocket pouch are pulled out for illustration purposes.



As an aside the maker of the RKBA, Stephen McElroy, has retired from holster making.

This message has been edited. Last edited by: bald1,

A few more pix



Rough hide out on the inside surface enhances pocket retention.

I use a pocket holster made by Aholster it’s a thin kydex and I have several

I am a huge fan of my Ryan Grizzle pocket holster.
Tim