SIGforum
Jack of All Trades Shotgun

This topic can be found at:
https://sigforum.com/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/630601935/m/4710071815

November 18, 2025, 12:31 AM
XLT
Jack of All Trades Shotgun
I have several beretta shotguns and they all work flaw less you are making a great choice.
November 19, 2025, 05:32 PM
IndianaBoy
quote:
Originally posted by usp_fan:
I have an A300 Ultima. It's been flawless at the range and in the field. Recoil is light. It's easy to break down and clean. I wish the design would allow an extended magazine tube, but it doesn't. If you can find one at the price you like, it'd be hard to go wrong.


https://nordiccomp.com/categor...l-mxt-extension-kit/


The adapter on this should fit your A300. You can get different length tubes that will thread into the adapter. I personally like to use a barrel clamp on extended shotgun magazine tubes.
November 20, 2025, 08:44 PM
Landchipper
We have three A300 12 ga.
Highly recommend it.


Too many SIGs .. ... Nah not really
November 21, 2025, 11:02 PM
usp_fan
quote:
Originally posted by IndianaBoy:
quote:
Originally posted by usp_fan:
I have an A300 Ultima. It's been flawless at the range and in the field. Recoil is light. It's easy to break down and clean. I wish the design would allow an extended magazine tube, but it doesn't. If you can find one at the price you like, it'd be hard to go wrong.



https://nordiccomp.com/categor...l-mxt-extension-kit/


The adapter on this should fit your A300. You can get different length tubes that will thread into the adapter. I personally like to use a barrel clamp on extended shotgun magazine tubes.


I'd be all over an extension, but the gas system on the non-defence A300 is in the way. The mag capacity is 2+1.
November 23, 2025, 01:33 PM
1KPerDay
No reason your 20” persuader can’t knock birds down just fine.

ETA: if it has a cylinder bore and is not threaded for chokes then yes, another gun would be more versatile for hunting.


---------------------------
My hovercraft is full of eels.
November 24, 2025, 03:59 AM
ruger357
quote:
Originally posted by YellowJacket:
If I could only have one shotgun it would absolutely be a Benelli Super Black Eagle II. It is the very definition of do everything, they run when they’re dirty and wet, they are slimmer and handle better than Berettas imo, and having an “only” shotgun that can’t shoot 3” shells would be an obvious dealbreaker.

I’ve got a bunch of shotguns but Id sell them all before my SBE II.


Exactly this.


-----------------------------------------

Roll Tide!

Glock Certified Armorer
NRA Certified Firearms Instructor
November 26, 2025, 12:07 AM
BB61
quote:
Originally posted by YellowJacket:
If I could only have one shotgun it would absolutely be a Benelli Super Black Eagle II. It is the very definition of do everything, they run when they’re dirty and wet, they are slimmer and handle better than Berettas imo, and having an “only” shotgun that can’t shoot 3” shells would be an obvious dealbreaker.

I’ve got a bunch of shotguns but Id sell them all before my SBE II.


^^^
The SBE II has now been replaced by the SBE III.


__________________________

November 27, 2025, 08:33 PM
YellowJacket
quote:
Originally posted by BB61:
quote:
Originally posted by YellowJacket:
If I could only have one shotgun it would absolutely be a Benelli Super Black Eagle II. It is the very definition of do everything, they run when they’re dirty and wet, they are slimmer and handle better than Berettas imo, and having an “only” shotgun that can’t shoot 3” shells would be an obvious dealbreaker.

I’ve got a bunch of shotguns but Id sell them all before my SBE II.


^^^
The SBE II has now been replaced by the SBE III.

Yeah but is it better?



There ain't much difference in the man I want to be and the man that I really am.
November 28, 2025, 12:18 AM
BB61
Yes. The biggest would be fixing the “Benelli click” in the SBE3.

What's the difference between Super Black Eagle 2 and 3?

“The Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 (SBE3) is an updated version of the SBE2, featuring several ergonomic and performance improvements like:

1. a larger charging handle and bolt release,

2. a more comfortable stock with a soft comb,

3. a modified bolt system to prevent misfires.

4. The SBE3 also includes a different forend and magazine cap design for a better grip and comes standard with a more visible red-bar front sight.

Ergonomics and controls


1. Charging handle and bolt release: The SBE3 has a larger, more easily manipulated charging handle and bolt release compared to the SBE2.

2. Safety: The SBE3 has a triangular rear-mounted safety, while the SBE2 uses a round one.

Stock and grip:

1. The SBE3 has a larger, softer comb, chevrons that are more defined for better grip, and a more defined pistol grip.

2 Forend and magazine cap: The SBE3's forend has a slimmer, more swooping design and a triangular magazine cap with grooves for improved grip, differing from the SBE2's straighter forend and round cap.

Performance and reliability

1. Bolt and action: The SBE3's bolt has an extra spring and a modified locking mechanism to prevent the "Benelli click" (failure to fully engage) that can occur with light loads, which is a common issue with the SBE2.

2. Trigger: The SBE3's trigger has more room and a different design to assist with the feed ramp, unlike the flat trigger on the SBE2.

3. Sight: The SBE3 comes standard with a high-visibility red-bar front sight, while the SBE2 typically has a standard bead sight.

Weight and balance

Weight: The SBE3 is slightly lighter on paper, with the SBE3 weighing 7.2 pounds and the SBE2 at 7.3 pounds, although the SBE3 may feel different due to a redistribution of weight.
Balance: The SBE3 often feels like it has more weight towards the front compared to the SBE2.”


__________________________

November 29, 2025, 07:39 AM
YellowJacket
Thanks ChatGPT. Do you like your III better than you liked your II?



There ain't much difference in the man I want to be and the man that I really am.
November 30, 2025, 04:10 PM
BB61
^^^
Well you all asked. Do you need to go out and sell your SBE/SBE 2? Probably not. However, if you hunt a lot, or pay for guided hunts, I’d say yes knowing you won’t have to worry about the “Benelli click” during your hunt. Which to me is the one major upgrade” Benelli made. However, I still take my classic Browning Auto-5 hunting and don’t feel outgunned so to speak. So I’m not all that worried about the gun anyway.


__________________________

December 01, 2025, 01:49 PM
YellowJacket
quote:
Originally posted by BB61:
^^^
Well you all asked. Do you need to go out and sell your SBE/SBE 2? Probably not. However, if you hunt a lot, or pay for guided hunts, I’d say yes knowing you won’t have to worry about the “Benelli click” during your hunt. Which to me is the one major upgrade” Benelli made. However, I still take my classic Browning Auto-5 hunting and don’t feel outgunned so to speak. So I’m not all that worried about the gun anyway.

Ha, I hunt with my Auto 5's more than anything else, as well. In fact, my affinity for the Benelli is based on it feeling slim and sleek most like my Auto 5s, compared to other more modern shotguns.

As for the SBE, I have never experienced the click, though I know it is well-documented. The other "improvements" don't actually seem like that to me. I guess they could be if one were wearing thick gloves.



There ain't much difference in the man I want to be and the man that I really am.