https://www.scientificamerican...-of-the-atomic-bomb/

Operation Gunnerside: The Norwegian Attack on Heavy Water That Deprived the Nazis of the Atomic Bomb

February 28 marks the 75th anniversary of one of the most dramatic and important military missions of World War II

By Timothy J. Jorgensen, The Conversation US on February 23, 2018

The following essay is reprinted with permission from The Conversation, an online publication covering the latest research.

After handing them their suicide capsules, Norwegian Royal Army Colonel Leif Tronstad informed his soldiers, “I cannot tell you why this mission is so important, but if you succeed, it will live in Norway’s memory for a hundred years.”

These commandos did know, however, that an earlier attempt at the same mission by British soldiers had been a complete failure. Two gliders transporting the men had both crashed while en route to their target. The survivors were quickly captured by German soldiers, tortured and executed. If similarly captured, these Norwegians could expect the same fate as their British counterparts, hence the suicide pills.

Feb. 28 marks the 75th anniversary of Operation Gunnerside, and though it hasn’t yet been 100 years, the memory of this successful Norwegian mission remains strong both within Norway and beyond. Memorialized in movies, books and TV mini-series, the winter sabotage of the Vemork chemical plant in Telemark County of Nazi-occupied Norway was one of the most dramatic and important military missions of World War II. It put the German nuclear scientists months behind and allowed the United States to overtake the Germans in the quest to produce the first atomic bomb.

While people tend to associate the United States’ atomic bomb efforts with Japan and the war in the Pacific, the Manhattan Project—the American program to produce an atomic bomb—was actually undertaken in reaction to Allied suspicions that the Germans were actively pursuing such a weapon. Yet the fighting in Europe ended before either side had a working atomic bomb. In fact, a rehearsal for Trinity—America’s first atomic bomb test detonation—was conducted on May 7, 1945, the very day that Germany surrendered.

So the U.S. atomic bomb arrived weeks too late for use against Germany. Nevertheless, had the Germans developed their own bomb just a few months earlier, the outcome of the war in Europe might have been completely different. The months of setback caused by the Norwegians’ sabotage of the Vemork chemical plant may very well have prevented a German victory.

NAZI BOMB EFFORT RELIED ON HEAVY WATER
What Colonel Tronstad, himself a prewar chemistry professor, was able to tell his men was that the Vemork chemical plant made “heavy water,” an important ingredient for the Germans’ weapons research. Beyond that, the Norwegian troops knew nothing of atomic bombs or how the heavy water was used. Even today, when many people have at least a rudimentary understanding of atomic bombs and know that the source of their vast energy is the splitting of atoms, few have any idea what heavy water is or its role in splitting those atoms. Still fewer know why the German nuclear scientists needed it, while the Americans didn’t.

“Heavy water” is just that: water with a molecular weight of 20 rather than the normal 18 atomic mass units, or amu. It’s heavier than normal because each of the two hydrogen atoms in heavy H2O weighs two rather than one amu. (The one oxygen atom in H2O weighs 16 amu.) While the nucleus of a normal hydrogen atom has a single subatomic particle called a proton, the nuclei of the hydrogen atoms in heavy water have both a proton and a neutron—another type of subatomic particle that weighs the same as a proton. Water molecules with heavy hydrogen atoms are extremely rare in nature (less than one in a billion natural water molecules are heavy), so the Germans had to artificially produce all the heavy water that they needed.

In terms of their chemistries, heavy water and normal water behave very similarly, and you wouldn’t detect any differences in your own cooking, drinking or bathing if heavy water were to suddenly start coming out of your tap. But you would notice that ice cubes made from heavy water sink rather than float when you put them in a glass of normal drinking water, because of their increased density.

Those differences are subtle, but there is something heavy water does that normal water can’t. When fast neutrons released by the splitting of atoms (that is, nuclear fission) pass through heavy water, interactions with the heavy water molecules cause those neutrons to slow down, or moderate. This is important because slowly moving neutrons are more efficient at splitting uranium atoms than fast moving neutrons. Since neutrons traveling through heavy water split atoms more efficiently, less uranium should be needed to achieve a critical mass; that’s the minimum amount of uranium required to start a spontaneous chain reaction of atoms splitting in rapid succession. It is this chain reaction, within the critical mass, that releases the explosive energy of the bomb. That’s why the Germans needed the heavy water; their strategy for producing an atomic explosion depended upon it.

The American scientists, in contrast, had chosen a different approach to achieve a critical mass. As I explain in my book, “Strange Glow: The Story of Radiation,” the U.S. atomic bomb effort used enriched uranium—uranium that has an increased concentration of the easily split uranium-235—while the Germans used unenriched uranium. And the Americans chose to slow the neutrons emitted from their enriched uranium with more readily available graphite, rather than heavy water. Each approach had its technological trade-offs, but the U.S. approach did not rely on having to synthesize the extremely scarce heavy water. Its rarity made heavy water the Achilles’ heel of the German nuclear bomb program.

STEALTHY APPROACH BY THE NORWEGIANS
Rather than repeating the British strategy of sending dozens of men in gliders, flying with heavy weapons and equipment (including bicycles!) to traverse the snow-covered roads, and making a direct assault at the plant’s front gates, the Norwegians would rely on an alternate strategy. They’d parachute a small group of expert skiers into the wilderness that surrounded the plant. The lightly armed skiers would then quickly ski their way to the plant, and use stealth rather than force to gain entry to the heavy water production room in order to destroy it with explosives.

Six Norwegian soldiers were dropped in to meet up with four others already on location. (The four had parachuted in weeks earlier to set up a lighted runway on a lake for the British gliders that never arrived.) On the ground, they were joined by a Norwegian spy. The 11-man group was initially slowed by severe weather conditions, but once the weather finally cleared, the men made rapid progress toward their target across the snow-covered countryside.

The Vemork plant clung to a steep hillside. Upon arriving at the ravine that served as a kind of protective moat, the soldiers could see that attempting to cross the heavily guarded bridge would be futile. So under the cover of darkness they descended to the bottom of the ravine, crossed the frozen stream, and climbed up the steep cliffs to the plant, thus completely bypassing the bridge. The Germans had thought the ravine impassible, so hadn’t guarded against such an approach.

The Norwegians were then able to sneak past sentries and find their way to the heavy water production room, relying on maps of the plant provided by Norwegian resistance workers. Upon entering the heavy water room, they quickly set their timed explosives and left. They escaped the scene during the chaotic aftermath of the explosion. No lives were lost, and not a single shot was fired by either side.

Outside the plant, the men backtracked through the ravine and then split into small groups that independently skied eastward toward the safety of neutral Sweden. Eventually, each made his way back to their Norwegian unit stationed in Britain.

The Germans were later able to rebuild their plant and resume making heavy water. Subsequent Allied bomber raids on the plant were not effective in stopping production due to the plant’s heavy walls. But the damage had already been done. The German atomic bomb effort had been slowed to the point that it would never be finished in time to influence the outcome of the war.

Today, we don’t hear much about heavy water. Modern nuclear bomb technology has taken other routes. But it was once one of the most rare and dangerous substances in the world, and brave soldiers—both British and Norwegian—fought courageously to stop its production.


This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR(S)
Timothy J. Jorgensen
Timothy J. Jorgensen is the Director of the Health Physics and Radiation Protection Graduate Program and Associate Professor of Radiation Medicine, Georgetown University.

How interesting! I knew there was a German atomic weapons research facility, but beyond that, nothing. Thanks for posting this!

Imagine what might have been. The Germans would have had the bomb and V2 rockets with which to launch them.

There is an awesome book detailing this operation. I highly recommend it!



https://www.amazon.com/Winter-...ords=winter+fortress

That is a great story, some real, no shit heroes there. I haven't seen any of the movies the discuss, or read any books. I'll be looking. Thank you for posting this

There's a great miniseries about this called "The Heavy Water War." If I remember right it's four parts and I think very well done. Its subtitles but worth the watch. It was on either Hulu or Netflix.

There are a couple of movies about this but neither one is anywhere in the neighborhood of what this story relates. However one I think is fairly close but I can't remember exactly nor do I remember the name of either.

This story is very worthwhile reading. I often wondered what heavy water was but never heard it explained this well. Thanks for posting it.

I am extremely interested in anything having to do with the second world war. I just last night started watching the mini series Winds Of War on You tube.

If you have Netlfix, I highly recommend watching the miniseries The Heavy Water War, which is an extremely well-made dramatization of the raid on the heavy water plant.

https://www.netflix.com/title/80073754

The book Churchill's Ministry of Ungentlemanly Warfare also does a good job covering the training, preparation, and execution of the raid in one of its chapters.

https://www.amazon.com/Churchi...ericks/dp/1250119022

thanks for the OP and the book link.

ordered the book

read about this a long time ago.

I vaguely recall a 50's or 60's movie based on this event. Anyone recall it?

there was "Heroes of Telemark" 1965

quote:

Originally posted by MRMATT:
Imagine what might have been. The Germans would have had the bomb and V2 rockets with which to launch them.

I highly doubt that whatever bomb they would have developed would've been capable of being put on a V2 rocket.

A fascinating story.

My only quibble with how some of those efforts and missions in World War II and other wars is that the authors often feel compelled to breathlessly claim that that was what “won” the war. The Germany atomic bomb project didn’t fail only because that store of heavy water was destroyed. There were several other factors that kept it from fruition, and probably the greatest was that it would have been about impossible for them to acquire enough fissile material to build one, much less several. The United States managed it with the best minds available, but it took several years of incredibly massive industrial effort and with no one dropping bombs on our sources of supply and facilities.

Even then the books I’ve read pointed out that after Nagasaki we had one bomb (or perhaps it was none) left. Furthermore, the German program wasn’t pursued very diligently. Werner Heisenberg, a Nobel laureate in physics, was in charge of the German program and he told the Nazi leadership that an A-bomb would require 10 times as much uranium as was actually required. That was such a large amount that it was seemingly impossible to produce under wartime conditions and therefore the project was not given as much support and effort as it might have been. Whether Heisenberg was just mistaken or whether he inflated the amount deliberately to sabotage the effort is still a matter of conjecture, but by the end of the war his team had made very little progress toward an actual weapon.*

Of course, most of all that was unknown to the Allies during the war, and that’s partially the reason for the effort to destroy the Norwegian heavy water.

For a good book on the German effort, I recommend Heisenberg’s War: The Secret History of the German Bomb by Thomas Powers.

* And if Heisenberg was mistaken, he wasn’t alone. When the first rumors about an atomic bomb began surfacing, Russian scientists declared that building one would be impossible and the attempt would be a waste of effort and resources. It wasn’t until after Communist spies in our program handed everything to the Soviets on a platter that they realized they were wrong and were able to build their own in such a short time after the war.

from 2012 (good article)

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/new...clear-ambitions.html

Hero of the Telemark dies aged 101: WWII commando carried out raid on Norwegian Hydro plant to thwart Nazi's A-bomb plans

One of the last two survivors of the legendary Second World War 'Heroes of the Telemark' raid, which helped thwart Hitler's plans to build a Nazi nuclear bomb, has died aged 101.

Just 31 at the time, Norwegian Birger Stromsheim was the oldest member of the team who successfully destroyed the heavy water production facility at the Norsk Hydoelectric plant in Telemark, southern Norway.

The raid, which is regarded as one of the most successful acts of sabotage in World War II, was also remarkable for the fact all the team managed to escape by cross country skiing 250 miles into Sweden.

I learned a few things in this thread.

quote:

Originally posted by RogueJSK:
If you have Netlfix, I highly recommend watching the miniseries The Heavy Water War, which is an extremely well-made dramatization of the raid on the heavy water plant.

https://www.netflix.com/title/80073754

I can't seem to find it on Netflix, and that link just gives me an error. Bummer.

quote:

Originally posted by sdy:
from 2012 (good article)

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/new...clear-ambitions.html

Hero of the Telemark dies aged 101: WWII commando carried out raid on Norwegian Hydro plant to thwart Nazi's A-bomb plans

One of the last two survivors of the legendary Second World War 'Heroes of the Telemark' raid, which helped thwart Hitler's plans to build a Nazi nuclear bomb, has died aged 101.

Just 31 at the time, Norwegian Birger Stromsheim was the oldest member of the team who successfully destroyed the heavy water production facility at the Norsk Hydoelectric plant in Telemark, southern Norway.

The raid, which is regarded as one of the most successful acts of sabotage in World War II, was also remarkable for the fact all the team managed to escape by cross country skiing 250 miles into Sweden.

The seated officer, front left, looks exactly like me at that age.

I wonder who he is/was?

tac

quote:

Originally posted by BamaJeepster:
There is an awesome book detailing this operation. I highly recommend it!



https://www.amazon.com/Winter-...ords=winter+fortress

Just finished reading this. Great book! As a veteran, I am in awe of what these men accomplished with the equipment they had available at the time and the conditions under which they operated. Truly heroic.

tac,

it's funny you asked that. I wondered about him too.

The article says that 23 y.o. Joachim Ronneberg was mission commander.

Joachim Ronneberg is now the mission's only living survivor aged 98.

I was wondering if front left was Ronneberg

edit: from looking at other pics, I would think that seated front right is Ronneberg

hard to believe he is still alive

quote:

Originally posted by sdy:
tac,

it's funny you asked that. I wondered about him too.

The article says that 23 y.o. Joachim Ronneberg was mission commander.

Joachim Ronneberg is now the mission's only living survivor aged 98.

I was wondering if front left was Ronneberg

That would be Jens Paullson who was the leader of the Grouse team.