Townhall.com
Jonah Goldberg
May 4, 2018

I am very critical of China's government. It's corrupt, authoritarian and in some respects totalitarian. I have deep reservations about Chinese culture as well. The Chinese government bans sex-selective abortions -- i.e., killing females in utero -- but Chinese people still do it in staggering numbers. China also practices ethnic discrimination that would be instantly recognizable as a kind of Jim Crow or apartheid if the majority Han Chinese were white and minorities such as the Uighurs were black. I could go on, but you get the point.

The reason I bring all of this up is that I want to be clear that my imminent praise for China is selective, even grudging. But you've got to hand it China. It has something we're sorely missing today: civilizational confidence.

Exhibit A: The Chinese think we're idiots when it comes to the absurd panic over "cultural appropriation."

By now you've probably heard that an American teenager wore a traditional Chinese dress to her prom. The young lady, Keziah Daum, is not ethnically Chinese or Asian. And this infuriated a lot of people on Twitter. Someone responded to Daum's pictures by tweeting, "My culture is NOT your goddamn prom dress."

And like Pavlov's dogs responding to the dinner bell, thousands of Twitter hounds rained abuse on Daum for the great alleged sin of "cultural appropriation."

Cultural appropriation was originally a sociological term to describe how a majority culture borrows or adapts from a minority culture some custom, fashion, cuisine or practice. At some point, alas, it went from being descriptive to proscriptive.

Proscriptive rules -- the opposite of prescriptive rules -- tell people what they cannot do. And while it's not quite a law (yet), save on some college campuses, there's an organized and passionate movement to pass a new social commandment: "Thou shalt not appropriate someone else's culture."

It must be noted that this is different than saying, "Thou shalt not mock or denigrate someone else's culture." That's a valuable social norm. But this is a distinction the anti-cultural-appropriation forces want to obliterate. They argue that any form of cultural appropriation is essentially indistinguishable from attacking someone's culture.

And that is idiotic.

Without cultural appropriation, American blacks would never have picked up European musical instruments to create the blues and jazz. Without cultural appropriation, white and black artists alike would never have spun these wonderful creations into rock and roll.

Nearly every meal you've ever eaten is the byproduct of centuries of cultural appropriation, to one extent or another. This column is written in English, a language that contains hundreds of thousands of words appropriated from other tongues. Just under two-thirds of our language derives from Latin or French. About a quarter is Germanic in origin. And about a sixth comes from Greek, Arabic and other languages.

Christianity was a Middle Eastern religion "appropriated" by Europeans.

Cultural appropriation manifested itself in every society and civilization since the concepts of society and civilization were born. We are living through the greatest period of poverty alleviation in all of human history right now because countries in Asia and Africa have appropriated many economic policies and practices -- free markets, property rights, etc. -- that began as quirky artifacts of English and Dutch culture.

But Western civilization is a bit different than other civilizations because, until very recently, it prided itself for its ability to embrace, and borrow from, other cultures. To be sure, some of that appropriation happened at the tip of a sword or gun, but show me a civilization that wasn't true of at one point or another.

Alas, the Puritan tradition in America takes funny new forms. So today, people can appropriate a different gender, but don't you dare wear a sombrero if you have the wrong DNA, never mind invent a Korean taco or wear a Chinese dress to the prom. I don't take much pride in the fact that Chinese elites wear Western jackets and ties, but I don't see why it should offend anyone either.

Which brings me back to China. The New York Times did a great journalistic service this week: It investigated whether the Chinese were offended by Daum's alleged hate crime. The overwhelming response? Nope. Chinese social media and cultural commentators celebrated Daum's decision as a compliment.

But in America, unfortunately, some people are so insecure in their identity and so desperate to be offended they have breathed new life into H.L. Mencken's definition of puritanism: "the haunting fear that someone, somewhere, may be happy."

Link

I heard a phrase for this: Outrage Porn.

It is based in human physiology. The manufactured "outrages" cause the release of adrenaline and dopamine, which makes the body want more of it. Viewing porn has a similar, but not identical effect.

I guess the SJW's are going to have a really good time of it tomorrow. Jes sayin.

o5

quote:

Originally posted by Sig2340:
I heard a phrase for this: Outrage Porn.

It is based in human physiology. The manufactured "outrages" cause the release of adrenaline and dopamine, which makes the body want more of it. Viewing porn has a similar, but not identical effect.

I'm going to start propagating that definition in my circles. It's perfect.

quote:

"Thou shalt not appropriate someone else's culture."

great concept....but that's "YOUR" culture....

as such, <REJECT> the very concept

I’ve always preferred the Dollie Parton approach to being offended.

When asked if she was offended by dumb blonde jokes, she said, “No, because I’m not dumb, and I’m not blonde.”

Maybe some correlation, a gambling addage "when do you play a crooked table . . . when it's the only game in town". I think the same applies to of "cultural appropriation". When a culture doesn't have much to hang its hat on, play the victim, it's the only game in town.

quote:

Originally posted by Scoutmaster:
Maybe some correlation, a gambling addage "when do you play a crooked table . . . when it's the only game in town". I think the same applies to of "cultural appropriation". When a culture doesn't have much to hang its hat on, play the victim, it's the only game in town.

But the Left has so much to be proud of: Soviet gulags and imposed mass starvation, National Socialist death camps, China's Great Leap Forward, Cambodia's killing fields, etc, etc. When it comes to the mass murder of millions, we should all be afraid of leftists. Their capacity for murder is limitless. Honestly, they make the Jihadis look like amateurs.

JP's video has several great examples of how to be offended:

Link to original video: https://youtu.be/F-mju_gW3c8

99% of the twitter warriors "offended" by this young lady's dress, will don sombreros tomorrow and swill beer and tequila.

RMD

Everyone wants to have a cause. Something else I have noticed is how white liberal millennials view disability as virtue. I work in medicine and they all want to be diagnosed with something. They love talking about their anxiety and depression. As if having a medical problem makes them better than others because they have to overcome. It’s the same way they look at minorities. They look at them as oppressed which to them is virtuous. That is why they give minorities a pass when it comes to crimes they commit or bad act they commit. It’s actually way more racist to think that a person of a certain race cant help doing wrong things because of this perceived oppression. At that point you aren’t ascribing free thought and will to these people. They think of them almost as helpless pets.

I literally have no idea how to pronounce her first name. Silly Mormons...

quote:

Originally posted by Dusty78:
Everyone wants to have a cause. Something else I have noticed is how white liberal millennials view disability as virtue. I work in medicine and they all want to be diagnosed with something. They love talking about their anxiety and depression. As if having a medical problem makes them better than others because they have to overcome. It’s the same way they look at minorities. They look at them as oppressed which to them is virtuous. That is why they give minorities a pass when it comes to crimes they commit or bad act they commit. It’s actually way more racist to think that a person of a certain race cant help doing wrong things because of this perceived oppression. At that point you aren’t ascribing free thought and will to these people. They think of them almost as helpless pets.

Victims, the highest status known to modern progressives. Nobody is entitled to more respect, sympathy, credence, than a victim.

Victims of cruel, heartless fate, the Trilateral Commission, white male supremacy, the Jews, Alt-right, whatever conspiracy you can dream of or blame.

quote:

Originally posted by JALLEN:....
Victims, the highest status known to modern progressives. Nobody is entitled to more respect, sympathy, credence, than a victim.

Victims of cruel, heartless fate, the Trilateral Commission, white male supremacy, the Jews, Alt-right, whatever conspiracy you can dream of or blame.

And as per my college faculty training, victims don't have to prove others wrongdoing, the victim's claim alone is deemed valid.

quote:

"My culture is NOT your goddamn prom dress."

Said the ethincally chinese man from his American home, in an American suburb, in an American state, founded by American patriots, all while writing in English while wearing western clothing.