Thanks for the valued feedback and insights everyone,

I was looking at the Operator or Warrior carriers as I want side protection.

My use would be for home protection and for SHTF scenarios where I can carry rifle mags and any load outs on the carrier as needed.

Base on your insights, I think III+ lightweight plates would suffice as I do want to keep the weight down as much as possible.

I have worn levels II and IIIA. I hated them both, but the II would be my preference. It's going to stop most pistol rounds with no problem.

My thinking is this.... the threats nowadays from civil unrest, BLM type terrorists, and ISIS types are able to get rifles easy enough. Ambushes against Law Enforcement almost always involve rifles. Soft body armor becomes more of a hindrance in those circumstances due to added weight, limited range of motion, and making heavy breathing more difficult. Plates are just out of the question for average beat cops and civilians. Soft body armor is kinda like a seat belt in a 100mph crash in those circumstances, it might make you feel good but does absolutely nothing to help you.

My department switched from II to IIIA about six years ago. A II with a supplemental 8x10 trauma plate is plenty for LEO on patrol. I wouldn't wear my vest off duty for any reason it becomes more of a hindrance for the reasons I listed above. It would be FAR more beneficial to sharpen your situational awareness and get sub 1 second draw and fire times.

Just my opinion based on my experiences.

Doesn't the "A" in III-A stand for "Anemic"?

j/k

I just wear a Safariland IIIA soft vest I found on eBay. It is probably time to replace it. It has a trauma plate within, soft panel, for a knife barrier. I wear it on each patrol and very occasionally on opening day when it sounds like a war zone in the woods.

Reviewing the recommendations again, and keeping this thread alive.

I mostly followed this. I wear a IIIa vest anytime I play range officer at club pistol matches or go anywhere I'm concerned in the big city. I find it completely tolerable (mine is a point blank) and don't mind it at all in any weather or activity. But its pistol rounds. I'd never consider L2 or L3 as its simply not any real advantage and you give up a lot on ballistics. I'm a firefighter and I have a full set of IV ceramic plates with carrier in my response bag and I put those one when circumstances dictate. Those are really tough to handle for any serious activities but I can't see any downside at home. If I have concerns about investigating something I just sling the carrier on and go.
I do get mine Xrayed once in awhile but steel is so much heavier that's worth it.
FWIW>

I've got AR500 plates in a condor carrier. So far it's main use has been extra weight when doing pull ups. Hope to keep it that way.

quote:

Originally posted by 4MUL8R:
I just wear a Safariland IIIA soft vest I found on eBay...

I wear it on each patrol and very occasionally on opening day when it sounds like a war zone in the woods.

Keep in mind that a IIIA vest will not stop a rifle round. So it won't do much good when some liquored-up Fudd on opening day mistakes you for Bambi.

Reviving this thread to solicit feedback from our members who have purchased from any of the vendors listed. I see where some no longer seem to have web sites, and others no longer have the referenced products available. Any good first hand knowledge of soft armor, whether it be II or IIIa? Thanks.

FYI -
To the folks who are buying the steel plates, if they're simply the wrinkle painted plates they offer zero Spall / Frag protection to the wearer.
The Line-X coated ones do but if shot near the edge they also won't stop all the Frag / Spall.

AR500.com (who sells the Line-X coated plates) also offers a Spall / Frag liner that wraps the plates to stop any Spall or Fram from causing secondary wounds to the wearer.

I was just informed that they're back in stock after almost a year of being out of stock.

https://www.ar500armor.com/ar5...and-frag-shield.html

I use a 5.11 plate carrier for working out. Then my son started using it, so I bought him one for Christmas.

I wanted contoured plates, since the plates I had were flat, so I bought some contoured CATI Level III plates. My main concern, was since we use these for working out, I wanted an identical weight as the steel plates. So I bought a pair, and my son and I both wear them in the front of the vest. The back plates are just steel plates.

They were on sale, something like $85 for the pair. Supposed to stop up to a .308. And I usually have it in my car, since it gets covered in sweat, and needs to dry out. It weighs 20lbs, but you really don't notice it. I wear it around the house, just because, well, I don't know.

Will I ever need it? I really hope not. But how many 15y/o kids can tell their friends they have a bullet proof vest? I saw a video of a guy shoot 50 slugs from a 12 gauge, and it held up. Yes, a faster moving bullet hitting it multiple times will cause failure.

I have an XL sized condor plate carrier with contoured III++ AR500 coated plates front and rear (11x14), and soft side plates. Some fancy useful stuff attached to it (including a blow out kit). It travels in my truck with me every time I leave town. Times are crazy.

so Para - did you ever make a decision?

RMA has Lev. 4 plates on special. Its actually $20.00 cheaper if you order separately though.

ARMOUR CHART

https://rmadefense.com/the-armor/

https://rmadefense.com/product...w-model-1155-plates/

https://rmadefense.com/product...late-model-1155-set/

https://rmadefense.com/product...rator-plate-carrier/

Oh under clothing was it. Well they do offer IIIA (1.47# plate) & IIIA+ (2.53# plate) as well (see chart).

This message has been edited. Last edited by: rpm2010,

For those looking at hard armor, a few things to consider. This is coming from someone who started with steel plates.

Full coat AR500 plates are great for those on a budget. You can usually get a pair of Level 3 plates for the price of a single plate with a higher rating. The question is now are you comfortable using them alone without a spall sleeve, as Grumpy Biker addressed above. Regarding spalling, one quote that stuck with me is "There is no tourniquet for the neck". I bought a spall sleeve for my front plate, and the combination barely fit in the carrier. Not a cheap carrier either, it's a Mayflower low pro.

Unncomfortable with the possibility of the front plate coming loose, the total weight and with a better budget, I replaced the steel with Hesco 4400 ceramic composite Level 4 plates. Thicker than stand alone steel, but higher rating and no need for a spall sleeve. Also fits in the carrier securely.

Weight difference is 19.4# for a pair of steel versus 14.4# for composites. The trade off is cost, and how much weight you want to wear. If you're goal is a carrier for SHTF, that 5# difference is a few magazines, but the weight savings will be paid out of pocket up front.

Look at individual manufacturers descriptions regarding "plate cut". Look up and compare pics. The particular brand steels I started with were advertised as "shooters cut", which was close to "SAPI cut". They were unforgiving when shouldering a rifle. Either find the sweet spot, or place the butt over the chest. The Hesco "swimmers cut" have a bit less coverage but are much easier to quickly shoulder with a good sight picture.

Sheesh, gotta get some sleep. Hope this is informative for someone!

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Just so you know your post wasn't in vain, it was VERY helpful for me. Thanks for sacrificing your sleep to post! My primary interest in personal body armor is for the day the SHTF. And that would probably be the day Civil War Part Deux starts or Texas falls to the Libtards or is invaded by Mexico. Well...I guess it already has been invaded...

My go-to site: https://www.spartanarmorsystems.com/

I'm sure I posted it early in the thread as well. They have a wide range of options from low cost ~$50/plate unfinished steel to lightweight high end composites. They have frequent sale pricing, LE/Mil discount and shipping is included.

quote:

Originally posted by IHooah:
If you are getting soft body armor and plan to wear it regularly it's important to get your correct measurememts. The crucial areas are where the armor wraps around your kidney area. You have to decide if you want overlap in the panels. With overlap you get full protection but it makes the armor much thicker and bulkier where it overlaps. Its more common to have it fit so the panels just touch but this requires a proper measurement.

1" overlap is the norm in law enforcement soft armor.

quote:

Wearing a moisture wicking shirt under armor makes a huge difference. Cotton will become soaked amd feels like burlap.

Agreed. I wear Under Armor. (Literally.) Pricey, but worth it.

quote:

It's important to wear soft or hard armor correctly. You want the top of the armor to rest right at the bottom of your clavicle notch. The back panel should match this height.

Soft armor is typically measured to fit from the roughly the sternum to the navel. Any longer and when you sit down, the bottom of the vest hits your belt and the top of the vest jabs into your throat.

The protection should meet and exceed the threat.

quote:

Originally posted by 94hokie:
Reviving this thread to solicit feedback from our members who have purchased from any of the vendors listed. I see where some no longer seem to have web sites, and others no longer have the referenced products available. Any good first hand knowledge of soft armor, whether it be II or IIIa? Thanks.

To address the re-pop of the thread.

I have not had any experience buying directly from a direct vendor of first hand products, nor of bullet-proof-me for 2nd hand products.

I like the idea of bullet-proof-me because they do provide A LOT of information.

I have, however, bought stuff from classifieds of other forums or ebay.

I got ripped off twice... once was zylon (the recalled material). The other was a person who took single sheets of Kevlar and glued them together. Both times I provided negative feedback directly (ebay) or indirectly (another forum/mgmt).

The zylon stuff we shot up at a sigforum shoot a long time ago. Interestinly, it still stopped the 9mm bullets... LOL. I threw away the "homemade" stuff and kept the carrier.

I have 2 real "vests" now, and a bunch of panels that I want to shoot up more.

The real ones are a EMS/Fire protective vest, which provides full coverage, and some ProTech IIIA panels that fit into a quilted carrier that really doesn't "print" like a vest, looks more like a winter ski vest (works well here in CO).

So, long story, but look around and try to find something that you can use and that is "real". The biggest thing to do is to make sure you wear it. Having any level of protection (IIA, II, IIIA, or even III+ plates) and leaving it at home defeats the purpose.

Just my 2 cents.

James

PS I actually have plates too, no real need for them given my personal life, but cool none-the-less.