Originally posted by sns3guppy:
quote:
Originally posted by maladat:
quote:
Originally posted by sns3guppy:
A comparison between the C-5 and the Birch Bitch (as the H-4 "Spruce Goose" was called in the day) isn't a very good one.
The H-4 made one flight, reaching a cruise altitude of 70', and remained airborne for a distance of less than a mile. It never flew again.
The C-5 does a bit better.
It does fly nose-low over corn fields, though.
It was designed as a military transport plane for use during World War II, but it wasn't finished until 1947. At that point it was an incredibly expensive novelty no one had a use for anymore.
It didn't fly again because the project was abandoned, not because the plane was unable to fly.
Hughes flew it, and spent a considerable sum in the day on it. He could easily have pursued what had become an obsession for him. It would have flown, but it would never had made the projections, nor would it have ever been more than a novelty. The fact remains, however, that it's a ridiculous comparison against the C-5 or any modern turbine transport.
The empty weight isn't so relevant as what the aircraft can do with the weight, and how much more it can carry, how far, and how fast.