My favorite Sig for EDC is my M11-A1. That was the last couple years. For the 12 or 14 years before that it was my P229/.40. However, lately I must confess I've been carrying an XD-S/9. I know, not a Sig, but I felt like I should come clean with that. Now that it's getting cooler I'll probably go back to the M11-A1 again. It's just such a magical tool.
Edited to fix stupid typos!
Regards From Sunny Tucson, SigFan
"Faith isn't believing that God can; it's knowing that He will." (From a sign on a church in Nicholasville, Kentucky)
Originally posted by Kelleytoons: Just to sum up this thread (so far) with actual numbers, the following are pistols that received more than two votes (almost every single Sig was represented by at least one vote):
(Note: I've grouped all the 229/228 variations into one lump because they are all so similar as to not needing breaking out)
I'm actually surprised the P228/9 platform got so many votes (even though it's the one I carry now) given the size disparity between it and the other two top popular choices.
I'd post similar poll results on caliber except that in many cases folks didn't say and the pistols they are carrying are offered in different ones so hard to make an assumption. My gut tells me that 9mm is still by far the most popular, with 45ACP coming in second but I could be mistaken.
Add one more 228/229 to the tally. M11-A1 for me, though truthfully I hardly ever carry. Can't during the work week, and get lazy on the weekends a lot of the time.
My take away from this thread is I need either a 239 or 225-A1 to add to rotation.
A couple SIGs and a few others
Posts: 8496 | Location: Loudoun County, Virginia | Registered: December 27, 2014
Interesting you mention that -- about a month ago I added a P225-A1 to my own rotation. It fits my M11A1 holster just fine, and even though it's only a quarter pound lighter it *seems* easier to carry (for one thing the slimmer grip prints less). It's kind of my go-to summer carry from now on (although that won't happen again for six months or so). It is also the best trigger of ANY Sig I own (including my M11A1, which I had Sig work on).
I'd like to shoot a P239 sometime just to see if I'd like it (heck, I'd even like to handle one -- gun shops around here seldom get any Sigs).
Mike "ex-genius" Kelley
Posts: 370 | Location: Central Florida | Registered: July 13, 2016
I also have an update to my edc. Shortly after I posted here I bought a legacy non-rail P229, and it has become my new favorite. I carry it in a Black Point Tactical OWB leather wing holster with a matching double mag pouch. I have .357 Sig and .40 barrels, and carry it in the .357 configuration. I switched mainly for the capacity increase for the same size set up as my P220 compact, and I've become a fan of the .357 Sig round.
My current fav - the 239 I picked up last month at a gun show. I thought it was a great deal for $500. I added the Nills for $160. Just a bit more comfortable to carry aiwb than my 229, or my 228, or my P6, or my 225A & I prefer the MOA to my 938. That was my excuse anyway. No rail, no tail, nothing on the slide, sweet trigger on this one and... two tone!